Overview
Europe’s nascent industrial policy on AI is gaining steady momentum, potentially allocating significant public and private funds and shaping regulatory actions in ways that will set the trajectory for years to come. This effort needs urgent public scrutiny. That is where this report intervenes: to ask hard questions of how resources are allocated, the process by which priorities will be decided, and most fundamentally, to examine the premises underlying its vision. What kind of (digital) future does Europe want? What role can, and should, AI technologies play? And who will have a say in determining these answers?
Rather than accept the narrow and poorly defined motivations of competitiveness and sovereignty that dominate conversations about AI, the authors in this collection redirect towards alternative pathways for Europe’s AI industrial policy – challenging concentrated power in the tech industry rather than entrenching it, and foregrounding benefit to the public and the planet

I. Reorienting European AI and Innovation Policy
Frederike Kaltheuner, Leevi Saari, Amba Kak, and Dr. Sarah Myers West

II. Europe Needs an EC-Led AI Plan for the People and the Planet
Dr. Cecilia Rikap

IV. Predatory Delay and Other Myths of “Sustainable AI”
Dr. Fieke Jansen and Michelle Thorne

V. From Infrastructural Power to Redistribution: How the EU’s Digital Agenda Cements Securitization and Computational Infrastructures (and How We Build Otherwise)
Sarah Chander and Assoc. Prof. Seda Gürses

VI. Lessons from the EU Chips Act on Public-Interest Guarantees
Margarida Silva and Dr. Jeroen Merk

VII. Public Procurement as a Lever for Change
MEP Kim Van Sparrentak and Simona de Heer


X. European Digital Independence: Building the EuroStack
Assoc. Prof. Francesca Bria

XI. Why Europe’s Cloud Ambitions Have Failed
Interview by Mark Scott, with Francesco Bonfiglio

XII. Toward Public Digital Infrastructure: From Hype to Public Value
Dr. Zuzanna Warso
Contributors
Cecilia Rikap
Cristina Caffarra
Fieke Jansen
Michelle Thorne
Sarah Chander
Seda Gürses
Margarida Silva
Jeroen Merk
MEP Kim Van Sparrentak
Simona de Heer
Burcu Kilic
Udbhav Tiwari
Francesca Bria
Mark Scott
Francesco Bonfiglio
Zuzanna Warso
Acknowledgments
This collection of essays was curated and edited by Frederike Kaltheuner, Leevi Saari, Amba Kak and Sarah Myers West, with operational support from Ellen Schwartz.
We are thankful to the authors of the essays in this collection for their generative collaboration. Special thanks to Robin Berjon and Max von Thun, for their feedback on the introductory chapter, and to Alek Tarkowski, Andrew Strait, Connor Dunlop, Daniel Leufer, Ella Jakubowska, Justin Nogarede, Lea Gimpel, Mark Dempsey, Mathias Vermeulen, Matthias Spielkamp, Maximilian Gahntz, Meredith Whittaker, Raegan MacDonald, and Tanya O’Carroll for their insights and feedback on the overall framing for this project. We would also like to thank the organizers and participants of the Antitrust, Regulation and the Next World Order conference, the Global AI Political Economy Meeting in Mexico, the Rebelance Now conference, the Toward European Digital Independence conference, and the Edri Civil Society Summit for their insights and ideas.
Copyediting by Caren Litherland.
Design by Partner & Partners.
Data Visualizations designed by Spitting Image, Bengaluru.
Suggested Citation: Frederike Kaltheuner, Leevi Saari, Amba Kak and Sarah Myers West, eds., “Redirecting Europe’s AI Industrial Policy: From Competitiveness to Public Interest”, AI Now Institute, October 2024